In a significant development within the music industry’s ongoing battle against online copyright infringement, the US Fourth Circuit Appeals Court has overturned a landmark ruling that awarded major record companies hefty damages against internet service provider Cox Communications.
The billion-dollar damages ruling, previously won by major record labels, has been reversed by the appeals judges. This decision stems from the rejection of a crucial aspect of the previous ruling, which determined that Cox Communications bore vicarious liability for copyright infringement due to its purported control over and financial benefit from the infringement.
In its latest judgment, the Fourth Circuit highlighted that while Cox was found liable for willful contributory infringement, the decision to hold it vicariously liable has been overturned. The court emphasized that Cox did not directly profit from the infringing activities of its subscribers, a prerequisite for establishing vicarious liability.
This legal saga began when Cox was sued by BMG, marking a pivotal moment where internet service providers were held accountable for copyright infringement facilitated by their networks. Subsequently, major record labels pursued their own lawsuit against Cox, leading to the initial billion-dollar damages ruling in 2019.
The implications of this decision reverberate throughout the industry, particularly concerning the responsibilities of ISPs in combating online copyright infringement. The precedent set by the Cox case has prompted scrutiny and legal action against other internet companies accused of similar infringements.
While the ruling affirms the importance of combating copyright infringement, it also underscores the complexity of determining liability in cases involving online platforms and service providers. As the legal landscape continues to evolve, stakeholders in the music industry and beyond will closely monitor developments and their ramifications for digital rights and responsibilities.
Photo credit: Warren LeMay.
For more music industry news, click here.
To start your FREE trial of VELCOA, click here.
The post US Appeals Court Overturns Billion Dollar Damages Ruling Against Cox Communications appeared first on VELCOA.
Comments are closed, but trackbacks and pingbacks are open.